Joint Discussion Forum: Post due TUESDAY (4-28) 3 PM; reply to two posts by THURSDAY 3 PM

OT100_SP2020_JCatron_reflection2

OT100_SP2020_JCatron_reflection2

by James Catron -
Number of replies: 2

When we compare the Prophetic and Wisdom literatures of the Old Testament, it is important to first consider the audience of both genres.  Generally, the Prophetic books were written while the whole of Israel was in captivity during the Assyrian and Babylonian exiles and were “spoken in quite specific situations”. (Collins, 198) For instance, the book of Isaiah deals with Israel’s standing in the world as it relates to other nations.  Typically, the prophetic books were not only God’s revelation of upcoming events but also Israel and Judah trying to make sense of why they were in captivity.  Israel and Judah were individual nations who were overrun and taken into captivity and they were trying to make sense of it all. 

 The Wisdom books were written for the everyday reader and addressed right living, theology, thought or attitude.  Although some of the writers are unknown or speculated, the books are a collection of different writers who expressed sayings of wisdom based on their experiences.  It is believed that Solomon wrote most of Proverbs and Ecclesiastes however, Proverbs was more than likely written by a collection of authors.  In Ecclesiastes, Solomon expresses his discontent with life and Job wrestles with the theological dilemma of why bad things happen to good people but more importantly he wrestles with the meaning of faith. 

 Both Prophetic and Wisdom literatures are also similar in that they address specific issues and they all deal with faith in one way or another.  The writers of the prophetic books confronted how to deal with the loss of their temple and home while being exiled in a foreign land and how those events affect their faith.  In wisdom literature, the writers confront how their individual actions and attitudes affect their personal standing in the world and how that relates to their own individual faith in God.    

In reply to James Catron

Re: OT100_SP2020_JCatron_reflection2

by Gregg Kohlhepp -

Hello, James. I completely agree that the prophetic writings take on nationalistic issues arising from situations of exile, much connected to identity and community. In “trying to make sense” of captivity, it helps to note that Second Isaiah provides comfort, giving voice to the belief that suffering “may have a purpose other than punishment” (Collins, 257).  Interestingly, this issue of suffering has a strong connection with Job, as the view shifts from the doctrine of the prophets to conversations generated by wisdom literature. Here, the depth of Job’s experience with suffering brilliantly challenges divine authority, which ushers each journey of faith into a world of complexities.  


In reply to James Catron

Re: OT100_SP2020_JCatron_reflection2

by Kevin Smith -

James,

What stands out for me in your essay, is the last paragraph where you compare what the prophetic and wisdom books have in common. As you say, both books deal faith and its relationship to life.  The prophetic books in context in exile help them deal specifically with loss as a nation, and the wisdom books help them individually deal with moments of loss in their life, as vividly seen in the book of Job. This helps me see and appreciate how well rounded the Hebrew Bible really is; it has a faith message that is both individual and  corporate/community. Our faith isn't ever either or individual or corporate, its both. Your comparison also shows in context how a situation can affect our viewpoint; exile and making sense of what happened, versus peacetime (Solomon's reign) and wisdom.